🇷🇺/🇧🇾🔥 COME AND SEE (1985) – VF-27

⚖ MGC Lower Court Docket: Case File #082
Asset Title: Come and See (1985) – The Belarusian Swamp-Wandering & Live-Fire Shock Ledger
Official Registry Grade: Certified MGC VF-27 (Very Fine / Lower-Tier Circulated Art-House War Specimen)
Lower Court Jurisdiction: Lower Tribunal Room / Soviet WWII Historical Docket
Presiding Panel: Judge Dex, Chief of R&D, Chief Grader MGC, and Chief Justice MGC
 
📜 The Forensic Narrative Breakdown
Under the strict 5x numismatic magnifying lens, Elem Klimov’s 1985 Soviet war film strips away Hollywood heroism in favor of raw historical brutality—but once cinephile hype and film-school prestige inflation are removed, the specimen reveals severe narrative fatigue. Rather than a tightly structured war drama, huge stretches of the 142-minute runtime consist of teenagers wandering aimlessly through mud, swamps, and woods with minimal plot momentum, relying heavily on surreal art-house gimmicks and real-life on-set shock value to hold attention, locking the coin down in the lower VF-20 to VF-37 register at VF-27.
 
🚨 Key Planchet Flaws:
  1. Severe Plot Deficit & Aimless Swamp-Wandering Pacing: For over two hours, the narrative barely moves forward—substituting repetitive trekking through Belarusian mud, forests, and villages for coherent dramatic progression or tactical storytelling.
  2. Surreal Art-House Gimmicks Over Discipline: Frequent, self-conscious fourth-wall stares directly into the camera, bizarre fever-dream sequences, and the experimental reverse-footage Hitler montage at the climax pull the viewer out of historical immersion into heavy-handed art-house abstraction.
  3. Shock-Value Production Reliance: While the historical reality of the 1943 Belarusian massacres carries undeniable weight, leaning on real live-ammunition animal cruelty (shooting a live cow on screen) and on-set danger cannot substitute for actual screenplay structure.
 
⚖ The Final Judicial Decree
While its uncompromising depiction of Eastern Front atrocities keeps the coin out of the G junk box, the lack of a cohesive plot, dragging runtime, and reliance on surreal shock tactics strip away every ounce of corporate and academic hyper-glow.
Permanently sealed in the archives as a Certified MGC VF-27 Circulated Specimen. Case #082 is officially closed. 🇷🇺/🇧🇾🔥🪖🌲🐄
0 0 votes
20-39
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 %s Official Judicial Verdicts
Oldest
Newest Most Voted